Proposed Solution to the Performance Problem with SQL Server Scalar UDFs

This article is a copy if a enhancement request that I have submitted on the feedback section of the Microsoft Connect web site.  Here’s a link to the item:

You may have to log in with a Microsoft Live ID and then register in order to vote.

The PDF and example script can be downloaded here

SQL Server scalar User-Defined Functions (UDFs) have a performance problem that could be solved with an enhancement to the SQL Server database engine. Because SQL Server must execute each function on every row, using any function incurs a cursor like performance penalty.  However, since many UDFs are simple, they can often be converted to a single expression.  This suggestion proposes that a new type of UDF, the Scalar Expression UDF, be added to SQL Server.  Doing so would often eliminate the performance penalty paid when using scalar UDFs and allow them to be used more widely.  Using UDFs has the advantage of abstraction that makes code easier to maintain and so making them easier to use has substantial benefits.

No matter how simple a UDF there’s a large performance penalty paid when they’re used.  This penalty shows up as poor query execution time when a query applies a UDF to a large number of rows, typically 1000 or more.  The penalty is incurred because the SQL Server database engine must create its own internal cursor like processing.  It must invoke each UDF on each row.  If the UDF is used in the WHERE clause, this may happen as part of the filtering the rows.  If the UDF is used in the select list, this happens when creating the results of the query to pass to the next stage of query processing. It’s the row by row processing that seems to slow SQL Server the most. I’ve documented the performance penalty in chapter 9 of my book, Transact-SQL User-Defined Functions.  I’ve posted a PDF with the relevant section of the book and a complete example script on this page.  Click here to download.

Many functions already are or could be converted to a single expression.  I’ve done this for my clients to solve performance problems associated with functions. My typical solution is to evaluate and test an equivalent expression and then substitute the expression anywhere the function is causing a performance problem.  This is a tedious and error prone process that requires a great deal of testing.  While it can achieve order of magnitude performance improvements, it negates the advantage of abstraction that scalar functions provide.

Here is my proposed syntax for the scalar expression user-defined function using a Books-On-Line style:

CREATE FUNCTION [ schema_name. ] function_name ( [ { @parameter_name [ AS ][ type_schema_name.parameter_data_type[ = default ] }

[ ,n ]



RETURNS return_data_type

[ WITH <function_option> [ ,n ] ]

[ AS ]

RETURN scalar_expression

[ ; ]

Because we’re talking about an expression, including the return_data_type isn’t absolutely necessary; SQL Server could just return the result type of the expression.  However, requiring the return type improves function documentation, removes the necessity of adding a CAST as part of the expression, and keeps the expression UDF similar to the existing scalar UDF.

This suggestion is made with an implicit assumption that the SQL Server parser and database engine can do the same job of substitution that a human does.  It’s the kind of problem that might be solved with the right macro processor.

I have found that the implementation of scalar UDFs is causing poor query performance and therefore inhibiting the use of scalar functions.  This suggestion would eliminate the performance penalty from many functions while retaining benefit that functions provide in code clarity and reuse.

isotretinoin rx cheap rating
4-5 stars based on 172 reviews

However the principles of treatmentmust not be compromised.

It improves risk prediction for a future cardiovas-cular event and mortality above and beyond the currentglobal risk assessment methods such as the Framing-ham risk score.

Thrice weeklyregimen should not be used, because it isassociated with 2–3 times higher rate of relapseand failure among HIV positive patients, and riskof acquiring resistance to R is increasedcompared to daily treatment. Ventilation maybe provided by pressure- or volume-limitedmodes with manipulations of the inspiratory timeto compensate for changes in respiratory compli-ance and resistance.

Recently, pathogenic mutations were identified inthe gene called serine protease inhibitor Kazal-type 5(SPIIMK5), which encodes LEKTI. (2003) Blood pressurereduction and secondary prevention of stroke and other vascularevents: a systematic review. Regular physical activity has beenshown to improve both lipid levels and blood pres-sure. leukopeniaand anemia in animals have been reported after chronicadministration of hydroquinone and pyrocatechol, bothbenzene metabolites

leukopeniaand anemia in animals have been reported after chronicadministration of hydroquinone and pyrocatechol, bothbenzene metabolites. For an ado-lescent, the radius of signi?cant others is the peer group. To help the client into this position isotretinoin rx cheap ask him tolie on the left side, with the buttocks as close to the edge of theexamining table as possible, and to bend the right knee.

Seizures occur atany time during anesthesia and will go unnoticed in the adequately anesthetizedpatient. After parturition isotretinoin rx cheap the uterus nearly returns to its normal size. Coordinated actions of GSH and itsdependent enzymes which constitute the glutathione system isotretinoin rx cheap lead to detoxification of ROSand RNS; and electrophiles produced by xenobiotics. The peak-to- peak pres-sures (amplitude) are adjusted to achieve a PaCO 2in the range of 35–45 mmHg with a pH in therange of 7.35–7.45 as long as the pre-ductal SaO 2is >85 %. The suppressive role of GST-A1 in theactivation of JNK signaling by a proinflammatory cytokine and oxidative stress wasdemonstrated by Romero and coworkers in human epithelial colorectal adenocarcinoma cellline (Caco-2) with variable GST-A1 expression at different stages of confluence and in mouse3T3 embryonic fibroblast-derived cell line with a tetracycline regulated transactivator toinduce GST-A1 expression. The molecular mechanism is not completely knownbut may be triggered by high transmethylation rates and hyper production of Hcy [53].

Predicting delayed ischemic deficits after aneurysmalsubarachnoid hemorrhage using a transient hyperemicresponse test of cerebral autoregulation.Neurosurgery.

These doses should not be used for> 2 weeks at a time.

Isch-emic strokes may be due to narrowing of the artery from clotformation (thrombotic stroke) or from a clot breaking off fromanother location in the brain or body, causing blockage as itlodges in the smaller brain artery (embolic stroke). Female perpetrators of domestic violence are now nearly as com-mon as males (Rogers and Pilgrim 2003) but on average the severity of violence is greater whenwomen are victims. Further isotretinoin rx cheap RCmD accounts for approximately 30%of all diagnosed mDS. It has been recognized that sleep is anarchitectured cyclic process (Fig

It has been recognized that sleep is anarchitectured cyclic process (Fig. This process requires the proliferation and differentiation of cells of the mesenchyme to becomeosteoblasts, the bone-forming cells. All of these activities directed at the T cell immunesystem have wide-ranging effects on the ability of the T cells in the system to maintainimmunological homeostasis within the body. American Thoracic Society: Diagnostic standards and clas-si?cation of tuberculosis in adults and children.